The frog that survives ice inside its body
How can a wood frog survive ice forming inside its body?
Cryoprotectants and Extreme Freeze Tolerance in a Subarctic Population of the Wood Frog
Costanzo et al. (2015), PLOS ONE
Why it matters
Winter survival depends on preparation and cellular responses. This story reveals how an animal can tolerate an environmental extreme instead of avoiding it entirely.
What the study found
Winter-conditioned wood frogs from Interior Alaska combine seasonal preparation with a rapid response to freezing. Their protective chemistry includes urea accumulated beforehand and glucose mobilised from liver glycogen after freezing starts. In one laboratory survival trial, five frogs recovered after repeated freeze–thaw cycles ending at −8°C. The demonstration is specific to these animals and conditions.
What this does not establish
The five-animal survival result followed repeated freezing and thawing ending at -8 degrees Celsius. It does not demonstrate universal frog survival, nor survival of the separate -16 degrees Celsius biochemical group. Glucose and urea contribute to the adaptation; their sufficiency for whole-animal survival was not isolated in this study.
- The survival result belongs only to the five animals thawed and monitored after the repeated-freeze protocol ending at −8°C. Other experimental groups were euthanised for biochemical analysis.
- The 2015 focal paper's −16°C group does not supply a survival outcome; avoid combining it with five-of-five survival.
- Glucose and urea contribute to freeze tolerance; they do not abolish freezing or represent its complete mechanistic explanation.
- Reference wildlife media cannot be represented as footage from the laboratory or as proof of freezing/recovery.
- No human cryopreservation, resurrection, death, complete solid freezing or home freezing experiment claim.
Claims you can trace
Each factual claim is tied to its location in the original research. Background evidence is listed separately.
- Wood frogs can survive partial body freezing.Costanzo et al. 2015: Results—Responses to Freezing; Survival of Freezing; species collection in Experimental Animals and Acclimatization Regimen.
- The focal study used winter-conditioned wood frogs collected in Interior Alaska.Costanzo et al. 2015: Experimental Animals and Acclimatization Regimen; Responses to Winter Conditioning; Preparations for Overwintering. Costanzo & Lee 2005 Introduction pp. 4079–4080 supports woodland/forest-duff setting.
- Urea accumulates in preparation for winter, before freezing.Costanzo et al. 2015: Results—Responses to Winter Conditioning, Table 3; Discussion—Urea and Glucose in Frozen Tissues.
- Liver glycogen supplies glucose after freezing begins.Costanzo et al. 2015: Discussion—Glycemic Response, especially opening paragraph; Results—Responses to Freezing, Figure 3.
- Dissolved protective solutes help limit ice formation and cellular water loss; the conceptual cell illustration places ice outside cells.Costanzo & Lee 2005 Introduction pp. 4079–4080; Discussion pp. 4085–4087 (extracellular ice, cell water loss and intracellular solute entry). Costanzo et al. 2015 Discussion—Organ Dehydration and Urea and Glucose in Frozen Tissues.
- The survival protocol used three freeze-thaw cycles reaching -4 degrees Celsius, then a final cooling to -8 degrees Celsius; five animals were thawed and followed.Costanzo et al. 2015: Methods—Freezing Experiment paragraphs 4–5: three cycles to −4°C, 4°C thaw intervals, final −8°C; five subjects thawed for monitoring.
- All five followed animals showed normal behaviour at the first check, about 30 hours after thawing began, and remained healthy through seven weeks.Costanzo et al. 2015: Results—Survival of Freezing: all five normal at first examination ~30 h after thaw initiation; healthy during a 7-week follow-up.
- This result concerns a small controlled test of winter-conditioned Alaskan wood frogs; it does not apply universally to frogs or freezing conditions.Costanzo et al. 2015: Experimental Animals and Acclimatization Regimen; Methods—Freezing Experiment; Introduction and Discussion on population variation; sample/setting restrict inference.
Save the reference
Research that supplies the context
- Costanzo, J. P., & Lee, R. E., Jr. (2005). Cryoprotection by urea in a terrestrially hibernating frog. Journal of Experimental Biology, 208, 4079–4089.Extracellular ice, dissolved intracellular cryoprotectants, reduced cellular dehydration and damage; woodland/forest-duff context.
- The PLOS ONE Staff (2015). Correction: Cryoprotectants and Extreme Freeze Tolerance in a Subarctic Population of the Wood Frog. PLOS ONE 10(4):e0124029.Publisher correction inspected: Table 5 footnotes were misplaced during typesetting; the survival result is unchanged.
Visual sources and credits
The credits below identify the source and use of each visual. Reference imagery and explanatory illustrations are distinguished from experimental footage where present. Narration is synthetic.
- Ken Sturm/USFWS — Original media · Public DomainCropped to vertical and carousel layouts, resized, and displayed with editorial camera movement, captions and narration. Reference wildlife photograph, not the experimental animals or footage of freezing.
- Gary Eslinger/USFWS — Original media · Public DomainCropped to portrait, resized, and displayed with editorial camera movement and text. Reference wood-frog leaf-litter habitat photograph; not the Alaskan collection site, study animals or freezing footage.
Complete verification record
# TT-005 evidence review — 7 November 2026 ## Focal paper Costanzo, J. P., Reynolds, A. M., do Amaral, M. C. F., Rosendale, A. J., & Lee, R. E., Jr. (2015). *Cryoprotectants and Extreme Freeze Tolerance in a Subarctic Population of the Wood Frog*. PLOS ONE, 10(2), e0117234. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0117234 Original full text: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4331536/ The main article was read through PMC, including methods, results, figures/tables and discussion. Raw deposited data were not downloaded or reanalysed. No supplementary-only claim is used. **Correction inspected:** https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0124029 . The publisher restored Table 5 footnotes misplaced during typesetting. This does not change the survival finding. No retraction notice was found in the inspected PMC/PLOS records and DOI/title searches on the review date. Recheck before release. ## Separately checked context Costanzo, J. P., & Lee, R. E., Jr. (2005). *Cryoprotection by urea in a terrestrially hibernating frog*. Journal of Experimental Biology, 208, 4079–4089. https://doi.org/10.1242/jeb.01859 Publisher PDF: https://journals.biologists.com/jeb/article-pdf/208/21/4079/1253907/4079.pdf Relevant introduction, cell/tissue experimental methods/results and discussion were inspected. Introduction pp. 4079–4080 describes terrestrial woodland overwintering and cryoprotectants reducing the freezable water fraction and cell dehydration. Discussion pp. 4085–4087 explains extracellular ice formation, cellular water loss, and the need for protective solutes to enter cells. This paper tests urea protection in isolated cells/tissues; its in-vitro outcomes are not confused with the focal whole-animal survival cohort. ## Claim ledger | ID | Claim | Exact source location and boundary | |---|---|---| | C1 | Wood frogs can survive partial body freezing. | 2015 Results: Responses to Freezing; Survival of Freezing. Do not call them dead or entirely solid. | | C2 | The story concerns winter preparation in wood frogs from Interior Alaska. | 2015 Methods: Experimental Animals and Acclimatization Regimen; Results: Responses to Winter Conditioning. Woodland context: 2005 Introduction pp. 4079–4080. | | C3 | Urea accumulates before freezing. | 2015 Results: Responses to Winter Conditioning, Table 3; Discussion: Urea and Glucose in Frozen Tissues. | | C4 | Liver glycogen supplies glucose as freezing starts. | 2015 Discussion: Glycemic Response, opening paragraph; Results: Figure 3. Do not claim equal glucose delivery to every organ. | | C5 | Dissolved protective solutes help limit freezing and cellular water loss. | 2005 Introduction pp. 4079–4080 and Discussion pp. 4085–4087; 2015 Discussion: Organ Dehydration; Urea and Glucose in Frozen Tissues. Ice is extracellular in the conceptual cell illustration. | | C6 | The survival protocol used three freeze/thaw cycles to −4°C, followed by −8°C. | 2015 Methods: Freezing Experiment, paragraphs 4–5. Five animals were thawed for survival observation; the other seven cyclic-treatment animals were sampled biochemically. | | C7 | All five survival-test frogs recovered and remained healthy through seven weeks. | 2015 Results: Survival of Freezing. Normal behaviour at first check, approximately 30 hours after thawing began; not instantaneous recovery. | | C8 | The result is limited to a small controlled test of winter-conditioned Alaskan wood frogs. | 2015 animal source, winter-conditioning methods, survival-cohort size and population-variation discussion. No universal freeze-proof claim. | ## Numbers and scope that must not be mixed The repeated-freeze trial lasted 19 days; estimated cumulative freezing was 15 days. Frogs were not held at −8°C throughout that period. The final −8°C hold was 5 hours. Normal behaviour was observed at the first examination around 30 hours after thawing began. Five of five monitored frogs remained healthy for 7 weeks. The direct −8°C and −16°C groups were used for biochemical sampling. **The focal paper does not report a survival test for its −16°C group.** Earlier studies discussed there must not be combined with the focal five-of-five result. Glucose and urea are contributors to freeze tolerance, not the entire adaptation. The focal study does not experimentally isolate their sufficiency for whole-animal survival. Species, population, season, cooling rate and preparation constrain the interpretation. ## Visual accuracy requirements Use correctly identified *Rana sylvatica* / *Lithobates sylvaticus* reference imagery. Captions must distinguish reference images from actual study footage. A forest/leaf-litter scene may establish habitat, but it must not be labelled the exact Alaskan study site without evidence. Original cell drawings are conceptual illustrations: ice outside cells; dissolved glucose and urea symbols inside fluid; some water loss; no solid sugar coating, forcefield or frozen living-cell interior. Particle numbers, membrane thickness, ice geometry and animation timing are not measured quantities. Do not draw a fabricated temperature trace. A labelled protocol sequence is acceptable. Five frog icons may represent the actual five-animal survival cohort. ## Story and narration The opening names a wood frog and asks how living cells survive ice inside the body. Seasonal preparation and on-demand sugar explain a protective strategy; the small survival test supplies concrete evidence, then the ending returns to winter survival. This is not a claim of resurrection, a human freezing technology or a freezing experiment for viewers to reproduce. This wood frog can survive ice forming inside its body. How do its cells survive? In Interior Alaska, winter survival starts before the first freeze. The frogs build up urea. Then, as freezing begins, their livers turn stored glycogen into glucose: sugar. Together, these substances limit ice formation and water loss from cells. They help the frog tolerate freezing, without stopping it completely. In one experiment, researchers repeatedly froze and thawed winter-prepared Alaskan wood frogs, finally reaching minus eight degrees Celsius. All five frogs checked for survival recovered and stayed healthy for seven weeks. These were winter-conditioned Alaskan frogs; not every frog can do this. Their winter strategy: protect living cells while part of the body freezes. Narration: 117 words. Final production edits require a fresh claim check. Pilot only; publication is governed by the current episode/release records. ## Research and asset access limits The 2014 Alaska field paper (Larson et al., DOI 10.1242/jeb.101931) was considered, but its publisher full-text page was inaccessible in this review. Its abstract was read; its 193-day and−18.1°C results are **not used** in this pilot. The 2016 freeze/thaw paper (Larson & Barnes, DOI 10.1086/687305) was screened from its abstract only and is not used for a new mechanistic claim. Media licensing and download hashes must be added from the final selected assets; scientific paper access does not grant rights to unrelated wildlife media. The PLOS focal article and its correction are CC BY; this pilot uses original explanatory graphics rather than reproducing publisher figures.